MTG Shopper Australia

Find the cheapest Magic: The Gathering singles in Australia. Paste your decklist to compare in-stock prices across Australian stores, shipping included.

Pick Your Poison price in Australia

Pick Your Poison is in stock at 25 Australian stores, from $0.30 at That Game Store. Updated 10 November 2026.

Store Listing Price (AUD)
That Game Store Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.30
MTG Singles Australia Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.40
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
From The Deep Games (NSW) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Pick Your Poison 170 (Murders at Karlov Manor) - NMNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Pick Your Poison 170/286 (Murders at Karlov Manor) - NMNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Pick Your Poison 55 (Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive) - NMNM · Nonfoil $0.50
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $0.50
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Kastle Cards & Games (SA) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Moon MTG Pick Your Poison - MKM 170NM · Nonfoil $0.50
MTGAU (SA) Pick Your Poison - (MKM) #170NM · Nonfoil $0.50
Plenty of Games Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Pro Gamers Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
TCG Singles AU Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.60
Kastle Cards & Games (SA) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.60
MTG Singles Australia Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.60
TCG Singles AU Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.60
The Cardhub Australia Pick Your Poison (170) [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.61
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Pick Your Poison 55 (Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive) - NMNM · Nonfoil $0.70
Good Games Morley (WA) Pick Your Poison 55 (Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive) - Foil - NMNM · Foil $0.70
Good Games Morley (WA) Pick Your Poison 170/286 (Murders at Karlov Manor) - Foil - NMNM · Foil $0.70
Shuffled Pick Your Poison (SOA-055) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.70
The Games Cube Pick Your PoisonNM · Nonfoil $0.74
MTGAU (SA) Pick Your Poison - (SOA) #55 (Borderless)NM · Nonfoil $0.74
The Cardhub Australia Pick Your Poison (55) (Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.75
Inn Games (NSW) Pick Your Poison (SOA-055) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.75
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (Japanese) [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (Japanese) [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (Japanese) [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Geelong FoilNM · Foil $0.80
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Werribee FoilNM · Foil $0.80
Kastle Cards & Games (SA) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.80
Kastle Cards & Games (SA) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.80
The Cardhub Australia Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art) (120) (Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.86
Eternal Magic (WA) Pick Your Poison (SOA-055) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Eternal Magic (WA) Pick Your Poison (SOA-055) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive Foil - Near MintNM · Foil $1.00
Fabled Games Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Games Portal (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Games Portal (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Magic Hothub Pick Your PoisonNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Mana Market (QLD) Pick Your Poison - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
MTGAU (SA) Pick Your Poison - (SOA) #55 (Foil/Borderless)NM · Foil $1.00
Playmantis Pick Your Poison - NonfoilNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Playmantis Pick Your Poison (Mystical Archive) - NonfoilNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Plenty of Games Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] Foil - Near MintNM · Foil $1.00
Plenty of Games Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $1.00
The Games Cube Pick Your Poison - FoilNM · Foil $1.01
The Games Cube Pick Your Poison - Japanese Alternate ArtNM · Nonfoil $1.21
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (2021 Edition) [Mystery Booster Playtest Cards] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
The Card House Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.00
The Card House Pick Your Poison [Murders at Karlov Manor] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $2.00
The Card House Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art) (SOA-120) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
The Card House Pick Your Poison (SOA-055) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
Games Portal (VIC) Pick Your Poison [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $3.50
Eternal Magic (WA) Pick Your Poison (JP Alternate Art) (Silver Scroll Foil) (SOA-185) - Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive Foil - Near MintNM · Foil $9.00
Moon MTG Pick Your Poison - SOA 185 FoilNM · Foil $9.20
The Games Cube Pick Your Poison - Silver Scroll Foil - Japanese Alternate ArtMP · Foil $9.42
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (Japanese Silver Scroll Foil) [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Geelong FoilNM · Foil $10.90
GUF (VIC) Pick Your Poison (Japanese Silver Scroll Foil) [Secrets of Strixhaven: Mystical Archive] - Ballarat FoilNM · Foil $10.90

Buying a whole deck? Paste your decklist to find the cheapest combination of stores, shipping included.