MTG Shopper Australia

Find the cheapest Magic: The Gathering singles in Australia. Paste your decklist to compare in-stock prices across Australian stores, shipping included.

Painful Quandary price in Australia

Painful Quandary is in stock at 21 Australian stores, from $1.50 at Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming. Updated 10 November 2026.

Store Listing Price (AUD)
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Painful Quandary [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.10
Jenes MTG Painful Quandary|The Brothers' War|111NM · Nonfoil $2.40
TCG Singles AU Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.40
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.50
Eternal Magic (WA) Painful Quandary [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.50
From The Deep Games (NSW) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.60
Shuffled Painful Quandary (FDN-179) - Foundations - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.65
MTGAU (SA) Painful Quandary - (FDN) #179NM · Nonfoil $2.83
Area 52 Gaming (TAS) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Painful Quandary [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
Good Games Morley (WA) Painful Quandary 179 (Foundations) - NMNM · Nonfoil $3.20
Eternal Magic (WA) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $3.50
Inn Games (NSW) Painful Quandary [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.52
Games Portal (VIC) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $4.20
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Painful Quandary [Scars of Mirrodin] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $4.25
Games Portal (VIC) Painful Quandary [Foundations] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $4.40
Eternal Magic (WA) Painful Quandary [The Brothers' War] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $4.50
Mana Market (QLD) Painful Quandary (Foil) - The Brothers' War Promos - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $4.50
The Games Cube Painful QuandaryNM · Nonfoil $4.72
Magic Hothub Painful QuandaryNM · Nonfoil $4.99
The Card House Painful Quandary (Promo Pack) [The Brothers' War Promos] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $5.00
The Card House Painful Quandary [Scars of Mirrodin] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $5.40
Untapped Realms Painful Quandary - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $5.55
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $7.80
The Cardhub Australia Painful Quandary (73) [Scars of Mirrodin] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $7.90
Eternal Magic (WA) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $8.00
Mana Market (QLD) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) (Foil) - The Brothers' War - Lightly Played FoilLP · Foil $8.20
Kastle Cards & Games (SA) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $8.50
Plenty of Games Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $8.50
TCG Singles AU Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $10.60
Eternal Magic (WA) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $11.50
GUF (VIC) Painful Quandary (Extended Art) [The Brothers' War] - Werribee FoilNM · Foil $12.70
The Games Cube Painful Quandary - FoilNM · Foil $31.98
Plenty of Games Painful Quandary [Scars of Mirrodin] Foil - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $35.50

Buying a whole deck? Paste your decklist to find the cheapest combination of stores, shipping included.