MTG Shopper Australia

Find the cheapest Magic: The Gathering singles in Australia. Paste your decklist to compare in-stock prices across Australian stores, shipping included.

Nightmare price in Australia

Nightmare is in stock at 24 Australian stores, from $0.30 at From The Deep Games. Updated 10 November 2026.

Store Listing Price (AUD)
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.30
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare // Food (0012) Double-Sided Token [Wilds of Eldraine Tokens] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.30
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Heavily PlayedHP · Nonfoil $0.30
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.42
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.42
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.42
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.42
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.47
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
From The Deep Games (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Pro Gamers Nightmare // Food (0012) Double-Sided Token [Wilds of Eldraine Tokens] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.50
Ronin Games (ACT) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $0.50
Jenes MTG Nightmare | Wilds of Eldraine Tokens | 6NM · Nonfoil $0.60
Pro Gamers Nightmare // Food (0010) Double-Sided Token [Wilds of Eldraine Tokens] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.60
The Games Cube Food (0012) // Nightmare (0006) Double-Sided Token - FoilNM · Foil $0.69
Games Portal (VIC) Nightmare // Food (0012) Double-Sided Token [Wilds of Eldraine Tokens] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $0.80
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - Magic 2010 - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.80
The Games Cube Food (0010) // Nightmare (0006) Double-Sided Token - FoilNM · Foil $0.81
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic Origins] (ORI 282) - Moderately PlayedMP · Nonfoil $0.94
Magic Hothub NightmareLP · Nonfoil $0.99
Magic Hothub NightmareLP · Nonfoil $0.99
Magic Hothub NightmareLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] (W17 17) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic Origins] (ORI 282) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2010] (M10 107) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] (W16 8) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2014] (M14 108) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2015] (M15 276) - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $0.99
The Card House Nightmare [Tenth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Beta] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [9th Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2010 (M10)] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2014 (M14)] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2015 (M15)] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.00
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Jenes MTG Nightmare|Eighth Edition|150NM · Nonfoil $1.00
Magic Hothub NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Magic Hothub NightmareLP · Nonfoil $1.00
Magic Hothub NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Magic Hothub NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - Welcome Deck 2017 - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - 7th Edition - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Playmantis Nightmare - NonfoilNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Playmantis Nightmare - NonfoilNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [Magic Origins] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Pro Gamers Nightmare [The List] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Nightmare [Tenth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
Rhystic Nostalgia Gaming (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.00
The Games Cube NightmareLP · Nonfoil $1.05
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.10
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.10
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.10
Shuffled Nightmare (W16-008) - Welcome Deck 2016 - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.10
Shuffled Nightmare (W17-017) - Welcome Deck 2017 - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] (W17 17) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic Origins] (ORI 282) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2010] (M10 107) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] (W16 8) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2014] (M14 108) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2015] (M15 276) - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.10
The Games Cube NightmareLP · Nonfoil $1.14
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.20
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $1.20
The Games Cube Nightmare - The ListNM · Nonfoil $1.20
That Game Store Nightmare [Magic 2010] (M10 107) - Moderately Played FoilMP · Foil $1.20
Shuffled Nightmare (M15-276) - Magic 2015 - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.30
Shuffled Nightmare (M14-108) - Magic 2014 - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.30
Shuffled Nightmare (LIST-W17-17) - The List - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.30
Shuffled Nightmare (W16-008) - Welcome Deck 2016 - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.30
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2010 (M10)] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $1.40
Magic Hothub NightmareLP · Nonfoil $1.49
The Cardhub Australia Nightmare (107) [Magic 2010 (M10)] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
The Cardhub Australia Nightmare (108) [Magic 2014 (M14)] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
The Cardhub Australia Nightmare (282) [Magic Origins] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.50
Fabled Games Nightmare [The List] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Fabled Games Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 276 (Magic 2015 (M15)) - LPLP · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 108 (Magic 2014 (M14)) - LPLP · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 282 (Magic Origins) - MPMP · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 8 (Welcome Deck 2016) - NMNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 17 (Welcome Deck 2017) - LPLP · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare 107 (Magic 2010 (M10)) - LPLP · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Nightmare 8/16 (Welcome Deck 2016) - NMNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Nightmare 276 (Magic 2015 (M15)) - NMNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Nightmare 17/30 (Welcome Deck 2017) - NMNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Good Games Morley (WA) Nightmare 108/249 (Magic 2014 (M14)) - NMNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Bendigo FoilNM · Foil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Werribee FoilNM · Foil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Ballarat FoilNM · Foil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Werribee FoilNM · Foil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - GeelongNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - BendigoNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Tenth Edition] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Ninth Edition] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Eighth Edition] - WerribeeNM · Nonfoil $1.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [The List] - BallaratNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Magic Origins] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $1.50
Lots Moore (NSW) Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Moon MTG Nightmare - M14 108NM · Nonfoil $1.50
Moon MTG Nightmare - M15 276NM · Nonfoil $1.50
Moon MTG Nightmare - ORI 282NM · Nonfoil $1.50
Moon MTG Nightmare - W16 8NM · Nonfoil $1.50
Moon MTG Nightmare - W17 17NM · Nonfoil $1.50
Plenty of Games Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Plenty of Games Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Plenty of Games Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $1.50
Tabernacle Games (VIC) Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $1.50
The Games Cube Nightmare - FoilNM · Foil $1.52
The Card House Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Moderately PlayedMP · Nonfoil $1.60
The Games Cube Nightmare - FoilNM · Foil $1.61
The Card House Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.80
The Card House Nightmare [Magic 2010] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.80
The Card House Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.80
The Card House Nightmare [Magic 2014] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.80
The Card House Nightmare [Eighth Edition] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $1.80
The Card House Nightmare [Magic Origins] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.00
The Card House Nightmare [Magic 2015] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.00
The Card House Nightmare [Ninth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Classic Sixth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $2.00
Untapped Realms Nightmare - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $2.50
Untapped Realms Nightmare - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $2.50
Untapped Realms Nightmare - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $2.50
The Card House Nightmare [Fifth Edition] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $2.70
Untapped Realms Nightmare - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $2.90
The Card House Nightmare [Fifth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - Fourth Edition - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $3.00
The Card House Nightmare [Fourth Edition] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $3.60
The Card House Nightmare [Fourth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $4.00
Plenty of Games Nightmare [Fourth Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $4.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare (Foil) [Beta] - Near Mint FoilNM · Foil $5.40
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - Revised Edition - Moderately PlayedMP · Nonfoil $6.30
Mana Market (QLD) Nightmare - Revised Edition - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $8.40
Untapped Realms Nightmare - English / Non-Foil / NMNM · Nonfoil $8.90
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Ninth Edition] - Werribee FoilNM · Foil $9.00
Elemental Arcade (NSW) Nightmare [Revised Edition] - Lightly PlayedLP · Nonfoil $9.86
Games Portal (VIC) Nightmare [Revised Edition] - Moderately PlayedMP · Nonfoil $11.50
The Games Cube NightmareNM · Nonfoil $11.79
Tabernacle Games (VIC) Nightmare [Revised Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $13.00
Good Games Adelaide (SA) Nightmare (Revised Edition) - NMNM · Nonfoil $13.20
The Card House Nightmare [Revised Edition] - Near MintNM · Nonfoil $13.50
GUF (VIC) Nightmare [Eighth Edition] - Ballarat FoilNM · Foil $22.10
Moon MTG Nightmare - 30A 412NM · Nonfoil $140.00

Buying a whole deck? Paste your decklist to find the cheapest combination of stores, shipping included.